I Can’t Afford $1,800 Car Insurance – What Are My Options as a New Driver in NY?

Many cash-strapped Americans may be at risk of severely underestimating the costs associated with owning and maintaining a vehicle over time. Undoubtedly, owning a car grants you a degree of freedom that’s unmatched. However, Americans will be paying for that freedom, and its value, I believe, is questionable, especially in an era where it’s all too convenient to catch a ride on an Uber or Lyft.

nextstayCCSettingsOffArabicChineseEnglishFrenchGermanHindiPortugueseSpanishFont ColorwhiteFont Opacity100%Font Size100%Font FamilyArialText ShadownoneBackground ColorblackBackground Opacity50%Window ColorblackWindow Opacity0%WhiteBlackRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyan100%75%50%25%200%175%150%125%100%75%50%ArialGeorgiaGaramondCourier NewTahomaTimes New RomanTrebuchet MSVerdanaNoneRaisedDepressedUniformDrop ShadowWhiteBlackRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyan100%75%50%25%0%WhiteBlackRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyan100%75%50%25%0%

Not to mention it’s also worry-free, given there’s no need to worry about parking, navigation, and, of course, that dreaded traffic too and from one’s destination. It’s not just more convenient to go down the path of a ride-hailing service, though.

In many instances, it’s also the more financially responsible choice, especially for young, new drivers who’ve already taken a hit to the chin with the car purchase (or financing), driving lessons, licensing fees, and all the sort. With limited experience also comes a hefty insurance bill that may make owning a car a move that sets one back significantly.

In this piece, we’ll check in on a posting I came across on Reddit, asking what one’s options were as a new driver in New York City. Indeed, that’s not only an expensive city, but one that can be pretty frustrating to drive in, given the bumper-to-bumper traffic. 

Key Points

  • Owning a car in NYC has become obscenely expensive for this young driver.

  • Selling the car and going the ride-hailing route seems smart.

  • Shopping around for insurance rates is a must for those keen on car ownership.

  • Millions of Americans keep making 5 basic mistakes with insurance and keep overpaying every year, sometimes by thousands of dollars. But, it’s easy to avoid if you know how. 

What’s one to do as a new driver in NYC?

Driving in the Big Apple is about as tough as it gets, especially for those with limited experience. Add the priciness of the city (which also applies to car insurance) into the equation, and the big question that someone in our Reddit user’s shoes, I think, should be whether or not it still makes sense to drive or if it’s a smarter move to take an Uber or even catch a cab. Indeed, there’s no shortage of taxis in New York City.

Indeed, a $1,800 per month sum for insurance, I think, just does not make sense, especially for a young urban professional who’s just getting started in their career. While owning a car is a must for some who desire a certain lifestyle, I do think that foregoing vehicle ownership is the financially wise decision for the long term, even if one can continue to afford the hefty parking fees and absurdly high car insurance rates. 

Personally, I’d sell the car as soon as possible and look into a ride-hailing subscription (think Uber One) to drive costs of getting around NYC even more affordable. Of course, ditching the vehicle isn’t going to be everyone’s cup of tea, especially for those who’ve inherited a vehicle. Additionally, New York City has some of the best public transit in the world. Catching a ride on the subway, walking, or even skateboarding may not align with everyone’s lifestyle. However, I do think that the considerable savings and added steps to one’s day make forgoing the car the strongest option.

What about for those who simply must drive?

For such folks who just have to drive (maybe there’s a baby who’s in need of a car seat), I’d suggest shopping around for car insurance rates because, to put it frankly, $1,800 per month doesn’t make much sense, in my view.

That’s not only expensive; it’s an obscene amount that I could amount to more than a car’s value in less than two years! If a young driver has a track record of incidents (I have no idea if this is the reason the rate is so high), perhaps there is no other way to trim that bill than to take the hit to the chin and build a track record of safe driving over the years. 

In any case, this young driver should re-evaluate the true costs of car ownership and ask themselves if it’s getting in the way of their long-term financial goals. NYC is a tough place to drive, and with such high insurance rates, I think the opportunity costs of owning the vehicle are just way too high.

Most Americans Overpay Without Realizing It

Car insurance is one of those monthly bills most Americans pay without a second thought. But the truth is, millions of drivers are overpaying simply because the haven’t bothered to get updated rates.

But there are dozens of easy ways to lower your rates. If you’re a safe driver, have moved in the last few years, if you’re a safe driver, or forgot to check about bundling you’re leaving free money on the table.

I was able to save $530 on my insurance, simply by applying to new providers with updated information. And it only took a few minutes!

👇 Use the form at the bottom of this article to see if another provider can lower your bill without sacrificing coverage.👇